KMFRI Website

Publication:
A just and sustainable transformation: Bio-economic modeling of Lake Victoria's cage farming

Abstract

This pre-analysis plan as of October 20, 2026 covers work under workpackage (WP) 2 of a funded project. We provide the entire pre-analysis plan also as a pdf version attached here, for better readability. This pre-registration covers six distinct topics, each with its own objectives, research questions and hypotheses as described below, under the umbrella of a joint problem statement and data collection activity (a three wave cage farmer survey), for which the following covers sampling etc. 1. Problem statement Cage aquaculture in Lake Victoria has expanded rapidly, becoming a key contributor to food security, income generation, and rural livelihoods. However, this growth has occurred amid weak spatial regulation and increasing environmental stress, particularly from climate change. Cage aquaculture also contributes to environmental problems, such as eutrophication exacerbated by uneaten feed and faecal matter, which has recently gained attention in popular media (The Observer, 2025). The combination of uncoordinated cage placement, eutrophication, and deteriorating water quality has led to frequent fish kills, and associated economic losses. Teplitz et al. (2026) observed that algal blooms were present in 81% of surveyed farms in 2023, and reported to not only trigger fish kills, but also reduce fish growth and survival and clog cage nets. Over the last year, fish kills, defined as events with >50 fish killed at a single time, had been experienced by 40% of farmers in the survey. Okechi et al. (2022) looked at the potential of cage aquaculture to contribute to degrading water quality, but findings failed to show significantly degraded water quality near cage aquaculture farms compared to control areas, suggesting that cage farm operations are not (yet) the major driver of water quality deterioration. Another potential externality from intensification of aquaculture arises through infectious diseases (Teplitz et al., 2026), which can be transmitted between farms given the proximity (median 5m distance between cages of different farms, Teplitz et al. 2026) of aquaculture operations. In response, a Spatial Climate Adaptation Plan (SCAP) for aquaculture, which aims to regulate cage placement, could align growing production with ecological carrying capacity. While Kenya's statutory frameworks (e.g., Fisheries Management and Development Act 2016, EMCA) legally mandate environmental compliance and licensing, and a first round of mapping activities has largely concluded with a ready-to-implement spatial plan, practical implementation of the plan remains as of yet low. A potential strategy to promote offshore placing of cages could be to allocate spatially explicit production rights, including the possibility of tradable licenses. By redefining access to productive space and reshaping incentives for investment and production, this plan has the potential to substantially change the economic structure and cost-benefit distribution of cage farming in Lake Victoria. Lake Victoria cage aquaculture accounted for 76% of national aquaculture production in 2024, up from near negligible levels in 2016. By 2024, the number of farmers had risen to 634 farmers (Republic of Kenya 2025). WP2 of the project addresses the question of how these regulatory changes will affect production outcomes, profitability, and distributional outcomes across actors in the aquaculture value chain. The introduction of spatial zoning and tradable rights is expected to increase the value of suitable aquaculture sites, potentially driving consolidation toward larger, better-capitalized producers. At the same time, compliance costs, relocation requirements, and limited access to capital may constrain small-scale farmers, including women and youth, who have thus far benefited from the sector’s expansion. These dynamics raise concerns about unintended distributional consequences, where gains in efficiency and environmental performance may come at the cost of reduced inclusiveness and increased inequality. To answer these questions, we will employ empirical analysis of existing data and newly collected data from three survey rounds with aquaculture farmers. This will be used to inform a bio-economic model of a spatial aquaculture system in Lake Victoria that link ecological carrying capacity with economic decision-making across heterogeneous producers, enabling the evaluation of trade-offs between production, profitability, and environmental sustainability. By addressing these questions, WP2 seeks to provide decisionmakers with robust, evidence-based insights into the economic and environmental consequences of spatial aquaculture planning. The analysis will inform policy design that maximizes sustainable production while safeguarding inclusive participation and equitable benefit sharing. In doing so, WP2 contributes to ensuring that the transition toward climate-adapted aquaculture systems in Lake Victoria supports economic and ecological sustainability and social justice. Underlying this overall research topic is the potential tradeoff between the objective to overall increase tilapia cage farming production in Lake Victoria as well as its efficiency, while at the same time ensuring a just transition, and potentially supporting sustainable participation of small-scale farmers. Essentially, the question is how the lake as a resource can be used most productively for society.

Identifiers

DOI
https://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/r4fdx
URI
https://repository.kmfri.go.ke/handle/123456789/1689
URL
https://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/r4fdx

Citation

Lancker, K., Opiyo, M. A., Nielsen, R., Awuor, F. J., Ogello, E., Christopher, A., & Obiero, K. O. (2026). A just and sustainable transformation: Bio-economic modeling of Lake Victoria's cage farming. Open Science Framework. https://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/r4fdx

Collections

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By

Creative Commons license

Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as CC BY 4.0

Publisher

Center for Open Science

Type

Other

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Usage Stats

0views